Price versus value
Price is what buyers and sellers agree on right now. Value is what the business could be worth given the cash it will produce. The two differ often. Markets get excited, markets get scared, and prices swing further than the business does.
Fair value tries to separate the two. If the price sits well below an estimate, the stock may be undervalued. Well above, it may be overvalued. May. Because the estimate itself has error bars.
The discounted cash flow idea
The discounted cash flow method, or DCF, starts from one idea: a business is worth the cash it will hand to its owners over time. So you estimate that cash year by year, then bring it back to today's money.
Why bring it back? A dollar next year is worth less than a dollar today, because you could invest today's dollar. The "discount rate" is how much less. A higher rate means a lower value today.
A tiny DCF (illustrative numbers)
Say a business will produce 100 dollars of free cash flow next year and you discount at 10%. That 100 is worth about 91 dollars today. Do the same for each future year, add them up, and you have a value for the business.
Now change the discount rate to 8%. The same cash flows now add up to a noticeably higher value. Nothing about the business changed. That's the weakness and the lesson in one step.
Why a range beats a single number
A DCF needs guesses about growth, margins and the discount rate. Small changes in those guesses move the result a lot. A single target price hides that.
A range shows it. Low, mid and high. The low case uses cautious assumptions, the high case optimistic ones, the mid case sits between. The width of the range is information too: a narrow range means the business is steady and predictable, a wide one means it isn't.
Other ways to estimate fair value
DCF isn't the only method. Multiples compare a stock with peers: P/E, price-to-sales or enterprise value to earnings. Our guide on the P/E ratio covers the most common one.
Analyst price targets are another input. They are opinions with a time frame of about a year, and they differ from fair value, which is about what the business is worth. A sound view looks at several methods and checks whether they roughly agree.
- DCF: value from future cash flows
- Multiples: value from what similar companies trade for
- Analyst targets: opinions of research firms, with a one year view
What can go wrong
Growth assumptions that are too rosy are the most common error. Another is using a terminal value, the value after the forecast years, that makes up most of the total and rests on a guess.
Companies with no profits yet, banks and insurers, and very cyclical firms are hard to value with a basic DCF. Expect wider ranges for them.
How to use a fair value range
Treat the range as a question, not an answer. If the price is below the low end, ask what the market sees that the model doesn't. If it's above the high end, ask what growth the price assumes.
In Peakwise, the AI stock analysis gives a fair value as a low, mid and high estimate with the method named, a verdict of undervalued, fairly valued or overvalued, and a confidence level. It's an estimate to check, not a target or advice. Look at which assumptions drive it and decide if you agree.
- Check the method and its main assumptions
- Compare the range with the current price and the P/E
- Read the risks next to it
- Come back after the next earnings report, because estimates age fast
Frequently asked questions
What is the fair value of a stock?
It is an estimate of what a stock is worth based on the business, usually from expected cash flows, instead of the market price. It is an estimate, not a fact.
How is fair value calculated?
A common method is the discounted cash flow: estimate future free cash flow, discount it back to today's money and add it up. Another is comparing multiples with peers.
Why does Peakwise show a fair value range?
Because inputs such as growth and the discount rate are uncertain. A low, mid and high estimate shows how much the answer depends on them.
Is a stock below fair value a good buy?
Not automatically. The estimate can be wrong, and the market may be pricing in risks the model misses. Treat it as a reason to look closer, not as a signal.
Is fair value the same as an analyst price target?
No. A price target is an analyst's opinion of where the price may be in about a year. Fair value is an estimate of what the business is worth based on its cash flows.